22 January 2013 8:56 am | | 0


Share     Share       Share     Share  

Tunisia’s National Constituent Assembly

If Article 95 of the draft constitution on defense and internal security is unamended, Tunisia risks seeing the establishment of armed groups, some legal experts argue.

“No armed organizations … that are not under the flag of the national army or internal security shall be formed except under a law,” reads the article.

Tunisian lawyer Abdessatar Zaafrani stated to Tunisia Live that Article 95 not only poses a threat to the civil state, but also civilians themselves. The presence of armed organizations – operating outside of the state – would detract from the government’s authority, posited Zaafrani. According to German socialogist Max Weber, the state has a monopoly over the legitimate means of violence. In such a way, the state’s capacity to protect civilians would be undermined as well, he asserted.

The given article does not serve the ends of the state, Zaafrani asserted.

“The article 95 cannot be further from everything judicial, since the constitution is written by unqualified people,” he said.

Ziad Laathari, a member of the ruling Ennahdha at the National Constituent Assembly (NCA), explained to Tunisia Live that the debate over Article 95 has arisen due to a general misinterpretation of the phrasing in the text.

“There has been confusion in understanding the article. What was meant by the exception is armed entities like jail personnel, customs, and security providing firms,” Laathari said. “They do not fall under the army or National Guard category, but they are still the state’s responsibility.”

Article 95 will nevertheless be rectified to avoid loopholes and misinterpretations, assured the NCA member.

The potential authorization of armed groups is not the only area of concern in the article. Another provision allows for the legal prosecution of security forces in the event that their work performed “overthrow[s] the democratic regime or electoral legality.”

Such a phrasing would hold army and National Guard personnel accountable for their judgement of whether certain commands from their superiors undermine the authority of the democratically-elected government or not, pointed out Zaafrani.

Share     Share       Share     Share  

  From the same category

            

New Areas Around Chaambi Declared Military Zones

Pollution Ravages Old Port of Tunis

NCA Approves Judicial Body, Looks Ahead to Electoral Law

Motocross Racers in the Forests of Bizerte

            

Members ‘Freeze’ NCA Participation Over Reduced Sentences for Ben Ali Officials

Ben Ali Officials To Be Released in Revolution Killings Case

UGTT Union Nominated for Nobel Peace Prize

Six Security Officers Injured in Rouhia Clashes

            

Tunisia Marks Martyrs Day with Calm Demonstrations

Martyrs’ Day Remembers Protesters Killed Under French Rule

Four Police Officers Convicted with Killing Protesters During Revolution

Libya Border Crossing Reopens After Protests


Leave Feedback


  Follow us

Connect on YouTube Connect on Google+ Connect to itunes Subscribe via RSS Feed



  Latest Videos


Play Video

Motocross Racers in the Forests of Bizerte, Tunisia

Bizerte, the northernmost city in Africa, hosted the fourth round of the...

Play Video

Endangered Whale Brought Ashore in Tunis Suburb

Onlookers in the popular tourist spot of Sidi Bou Said, near Tunis,...

Play Video

'Kima Enti:' Mixing Tunisian Traditions With Modern Design

"Kima Enti" is a hand-made art and design project launched by independent...

Play Video

One-Year Anniversary of Chokri Belaid's Death

On February 6, 2014, family and supporters of slain Tunisian politician Chokri...

Play Video

Klay BBJ explains his arrest

Tunisia Live's Nissaf Slama interviews rapper Klay BBJ on his music, arrest,...



Tabbed Structure - Regular
UGTT Union Nominated for Nobel Peace Prize...
(1519 Views)
Unemployed Tunisians Risk Their Lives to Build Future...
(1289 Views)
Switzerland to Return $40 Million in Ben Ali...
(1186 Views)
Tunisia Returns Stolen Ancient Artifact to Algeria...
(1185 Views)
Pollution Ravages Old Port of Tunis...
(957 Views)
NCA Approves Judicial Body, Looks Ahead to Electoral...
(949 Views)
Motocross Racers in the Forests of Bizerte...
(924 Views)
Ben Ali Officials To Be Released in Revolution...
(860 Views)
Members ‘Freeze’ NCA Participation Over Reduced Sentences for...
(826 Views)
 
Low Turnout and Mixed Feelings for Algerians Voting in Tunisia...
Update: Libyan Kidnappers Demand Militants’ Release...
New Areas Around Chaambi Declared Military Zones...
Pollution Ravages Old Port of Tunis...
NCA Approves Judicial Body, Looks Ahead to Electoral Law...
Motocross Racers in the Forests of Bizerte...
Unemployed Tunisians Risk Their Lives to Build Future in Europe...
Members ‘Freeze’ NCA Participation Over Reduced Sentences for Ben Ali Officials...
Ben Ali Officials To Be Released in Revolution Killings Case...