• Headlines

    Political Turmoil Endangers Tunisian Economy

    By Farah Samti | Feb 21 2013 Share on Linkedin Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Google Share on pinterest Print

    Tags: assassination of Chokri Belaid , cabinet reshuffle , Chokri Belaid , Ennahdha , Hamadi Jebali ,

    Tunisia’s ongoing political crisis, fueled by tensions over the cabinet reshuffle and magnified by the assassination of opposition leader Chokri Belaid, may not have critically affected the country’s already ailing economy, but its indirect consequences are already revealing themselves.

    The country’s economy faced serious challenges even before the current political tension; but it has started to feel the impact of the fallout, according to economic expert Radhi Meddeb.

    “An immediate collateral effect is the downgrading of the country’s sovereign risk rating, limiting the country’s ability to access capital markets but also affecting the fluidity of the activity of local SME’s (small-and medium-sized enterprises) and their exports,” Meddeb said in an interview with Tunisia Live.

    Standard and Poor’s rating agency issued a report February 19 in which Tunisia’s credit rating sank further into junk-grade status, from BB to BB-.  Even though the downgrade preceded the resignation of Tunisian Prime Minister Hamadi Jebali, the instability of the political situation is blamed for creating a “high-risk” image of the country to international investors.

    And the tourism sector remains the most affected with “an unprecedented level of booking cancellations,” Meddeb said.

    Moez Laabidi, another economic expert, had a more optimistic view of the situation.

    “My evaluation of the current economic situation is that it’s not disastrous,” he said. “The economic machine is not broken; it’s only temporary.”

    Yet Laabidi acknowledged that the political turmoil has “polluted” the business climate and might disastrously impact the economy if the cabinet’s indecisiveness continues. 

    Following the popular uprisings of January 2011, the constitutional elections of October restored Tunisians’ faith in the political process after a period of shock.

    “People who were too afraid to invest after the revolution were reassured by the political maturity after the elections. … Now, the absence of a clear vision of the future made Tunisians lose faith in their leaders,” Laabidi said. 

    Before the official rejection of Jebali’s proposal to form a nonpartisan, technocratic government on Monday as a solution to the delay in the cabinet reshuffle, two potential scenarios were hotly debated: Jebali’s initiative versus a new government based on a political coalition. 

    Prime Minister announces his resignation Tuesday evening (Courtesy of the Tunisian Presidency’s official Facebook page)

    Economic experts welcomed the prime minister’s proposal pending approval of the National Constituent Assembly (NCA).

    “A technocratic government would have been an efficient solution as political coalitions always have side effects. … For instance, we stayed for a whole year without a minister of finance because Ettakatol was not able to find a qualified alternative,” said Moncef Cheikhrouhou, an economist who is also an NCA member.

    During his public resignation Tuesday, Jebali stated that he was still convinced that a government composed of technocratic ministers would end political tensions, and thus the country’s crisis. 

    “It’s a reasonable solution,” Laabidi said. “But if applying it means going against the NCA’s will, then it’d be best to avoid deepening the crisis, as the NCA represents legitimacy.”

    Additionally, he explained that the political coalition scenario could work if the constitution drafting process was accelerated and transitional bodies and laws agreed upon. Delays have filled Tunisians with doubt, and the government’s success may very well depend on its ability to gain people’s trust.

    The government is regarded to be primarily responsible for the country’s economic failure, said Laabidi, even though other factors have contributed to the crisis as well.

    “When people saw that higher officials at the government are assigning their relatives or in-laws in governmental positions, regular citizens started demanding higher salaries,” Laabidi explained.

    Economic expert Radhi Meddeb (Courtesy of his official Facebook page)

    As a direct consequence in the private sector, businessmen succumbed to union pressure and agreed to provide higher salaries, while raising the prices of products and services in return. The result was rising inflation. 

    In the public sector, similar demands for higher salaries have prevailed. The state was obliged to compromise and prefered to fall further in debt and avoid raising taxes.

    “We can’t realize the weight of the debt now, but with time it is becoming a huge burden,” Laabidi added.

    Reuters wrote that Tunisia has been attempting to reassure the International Monetary Fund by adopting more effective budget strategies in order to obtain a $1.78 billion loan. However, the mission has become more challenging since Belaid’s assassination, given the increased political tension among the different parties. 

    Both Laabidi and Meddeb agreed that Tunisia must adopt drastic reforms in order to end the economic crisis. But such reforms require a national debate and consensus. The absence of an economic model, based on sustainable and inclusive development, was one of the catalysts for the revolution, Meddeb said. 

    “Quick wins must be identified and implemented essentially at the level of job creation, education system, better infrastructure, and improving social conditions … through a better governance and a clear regional development plan … And this is doable,” Meddeb said.

    “These political tensions are not the cause of the economic crisis,” Cheikhrouhou added, but regaining the faith of Tunisians is a necessity.

  • By Farah Samti  / 
  • Topics

    People

  • Jebali
  • Chokri Belaid
  • Hamadi Jebali
  • Place

    Organization

  • Ennahdha
  • Related

    Comments

      Leo Africanus /

      I cry for you ya Tunisia
      to see you shaped by these barbues
      whose incompetence is their currency
      turning back time by centuries
      taking you hostage by ideology

      I cry for you ya Tunisia
      this was my Evita parody

      • Rob Prince /

        Although I wonder if more structural adjustment-like policies are going to help Tunisia out of its economic rut (as suggested in this article “the need for `drastic reforms’..) this is an otherwise very useful article that probes the economic issues well. The point that it was the socio-economic crisis which triggered the Tunisian Arab Spring in the first place is well taken.

        My initial sense is that Jebali’s replacement will not help the situation much.

    1. Chedley Aouriri /

      While this is a correct analysis of the frail economy in Tunisia, it fails to mention the weight and burdens of the legacy of the previous regime of BenAli. It also overlooks the negative impact of the economic recession in western Europe, the main trading partner of Tunisia.

      As to the “drastic reforms” promoted by the IMF, Tunisia should be real weary of them. The public budget and debt levels of Tunisia are such that it still can do without the benevolent reforms attached to the IMF loans.
      However, Tunisia must stabilize its political outlook and restore security as minimum conditions for restarting its economy.

    Tweets

    Popular posts


    Videos

    Silent March In Memory of Aya

    ...

  • Play Video

    Tunisia's Launch of Truth and Dignity Commission

  • Play Video

    Tunisialive Living Tunisia

  • Play Video

    #FreeAzyz campaigners protest gets violent


  • Posts

    In Pictures

    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live
    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live
    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live
    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live
    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live
    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live
    • Carthage Theater Days statue display in downtown Tunis.

      Photo credit: Tristan Dreisbach, Tunisia Live

  • Opinions